We get this question more than you’d think, usually at 11 p.m. from people standing barefoot in front of an open closet, whispering “it’s not cheating if it’s cotton.”
Short answer: Yes, you can adopt. Long answer: Communicate with all textiles involved.
Sandals are historically polyamorous footwear. They have seen things. They will not judge you for bringing home a lonely ankle sock — but they may develop jealousy if the sock gets more weekend trips than they do.
Our counselors suggest:
- Rotate companionship fairly between sandal and sock.
- Never force a sock into a Birkenstock without consent.
- Document your adoption journey on the Tales from the Drawer page so others feel less alone.
Love is messy. Laundry is messier. Sock Widow is here for all consensual fabric arrangements.

My sandal and adopted sock are co-parenting a flip-flop. It is a modern family.
Finally, a FAQ that treats textiles with the dignity they deserve.